SEARCH
Click for search help & more options

Cirrus mid-air over Boulder

rated by 0 users
This post has 9 Replies | 1 Follower

won Posted: 6 Feb 2010 14:50

Details at http://www.9news.com/news/article.aspx?storyid=132284&provider=top&catid=188

Appears that the Cirrus hit the cable of a tow plane just after release. Cirrus and tow plane crashed. Up to 5 SOB.

Be aware that the video imbeded with the attached TV news article is disturbing.

Link to This Post |

Extensive discussion on the members forum here.

 

Rick

SR22 N858CD #127 ARNAV/EMM35 Sandel Skywatch 3250 hours (SNEW!)

Link to This Post |

Did the Boulder Cirrus have any type of Skywatch, TCAD,  or TIS traffic alerting system on it?

Link to This Post |

David Rosing:

Did the Boulder Cirrus have any type of Skywatch, TCAD,  or TIS traffic alerting system on it?

We don't know yet.  Because my contacts at Cirrus Aircraft are parties to the NTSB investigation, that simple question does not have an easy answer.

However, the aircraft was a SR20 model, often purchased as an economical choice.  That may reduce the likelihood that it included a traffic advisory system, which is an additional cost option, but that's only my guess.

From witness statements and radar track information, neither plane were observed making any evasive maneuvers prior to impact.

 

Cheers
Rick

SR22 N858CD #127 ARNAV/EMM35 Sandel Skywatch 3250 hours (SNEW!)

Link to This Post |

Rick Beach:
However, the aircraft was a SR20 model, often purchased as an economical choice.  That may reduce the likelihood that it included a traffic advisory system, which is an additional cost option, but that's only my guess

Hey!! Watch the SR22 chauvinism!!!! Lightning

Mike

Link to This Post |

Michael Doody:

Rick Beach:
However, the aircraft was a SR20 model, often purchased as an economical choice.  That may reduce the likelihood that it included a traffic advisory system, which is an additional cost option, but that's only my guess

Hey!! Watch the SR22 chauvinism!!!! Lightning

Mike

I too resent being labeled an economiser. We fly SR-20s because we're adrenaline junkies, thank you very much.

 

-Sanjay (Down here among the unclean, all my good just comes undone.)

Link to This Post |

Sanjay Saigal:

Michael Doody:

Rick Beach:
However, the aircraft was a SR20 model, often purchased as an economical choice.  That may reduce the likelihood that it included a traffic advisory system, which is an additional cost option, but that's only my guess

Hey!! Watch the SR22 chauvinism!!!! Lightning

Mike

I too resent being labeled an economiser. We fly SR-20s because we're adrenaline junkies, thank you very much.

Wish this were a thread in which the humor made sense.  Unfortunately, my comment wasn't chauvinism.  It wasn't even humorous.  It was a reflection of the tragedy of the accident.

If the accident airplane had a traffic system on board, then why no evasion?

If the accident airplane did not have a traffic system, then why not utilize ATC to help in busy airspace?

 

Frustrated,
Rick

 

SR22 N858CD #127 ARNAV/EMM35 Sandel Skywatch 3250 hours (SNEW!)

Link to This Post |

Rick Beach:
If the accident airplane had a traffic system on board, then why no evasion?

Because there is the very real possibility that the towplane and glider did not have their transponder on.  This was a problem that was complained about by many pilots who did have traffic systems.  Myself and others I know of have flown through there and visually had visually identified the towplane and gliders in the air, but never picked them up on traffic.

C.J. Eliassen Airplane & Helicopter Instructor, CSIP, A&P IA

Et si omnes ego non 

Link to This Post |

Rick Beach:
Wish this were a thread in which the humor made sense.  Unfortunately, my comment wasn't chauvinism.  It wasn't even humorous.  It was a reflection of the tragedy of the accident.

I am sorry for sounding out of place, Rick. I too feel a sense of loss over any of these events.  I guess I was trying to use a little humor to point out that many SR20s are as fully decked out as any SR22. Humor has a huge place even at funerals and wakes as people talk things out and try to make sense out of what happened.

Mike

Link to This Post |

 

C.J. Eliassen:

Rick Beach:
If the accident airplane had a traffic system on board, then why no evasion?

Because there is the very real possibility that the towplane and glider did not have their transponder on.  This was a problem that was complained about by many pilots who did have traffic systems.  Myself and others I know of have flown through there and visually had visually identified the towplane and gliders in the air, but never picked them up on traffic.

As some know, I live in Boulder, and I fly out of Longmont, whch is North of Boulder. A few weeks ago, I had a near pass with a Tow plane and Glider from BOU. My Traffic didn't pick up the tow plane until I passed him. So I know they carry something.

I was upset that I could have come that close , and I went to visit the glider people the next day to get a better handle on how to get past the BOU airfield... the answer really came out,,best to stay well clear to the east if at all possible.

Anyway, to answer the question,, yes they, or at least this tow plane had a transponder, but I got the signal very late. This then asks the queston, is the traffic system worth looking at , my answer is, I have a real hard time spotting planes even with a half mile of me.

fred

 

N825FW SR22/G2 5 Window coupe Radio/heater compass and dual exhausts

Link to This Post |
Page 1 of 1 (10 items) | View All | Print All | RSS
Community Server Customization By CoutoSolutions.com
© 2012 Cirrus Owners & Pilots Association. All Rights Reserved